top of page

High Court at Mubende Annuls Bwekula South Member of Parliament's Election Over Compromised Electoral Materials; Orders Fresh Election, Finds Returning Officer In Breach of Statutory Duty.

2 days ago
31 min read

Snap Shot

The case concerned a challenge to the election of Mubangizi Dedan as Member of Parliament for Buwekula South Constituency, following a recount that reversed the initial declaration of the Petitioner as winner by 806 votes and instead declared the 1st Respondent winner by 404 votes.


The Petitioner questioned the integrity and reliability of the recount, citing discrepancies in the electoral materials, missing ballot papers and Declaration of Results (DR) Forms, irregularities in the packaging and sealing of ballot boxes, and failures to maintain a verifiable chain of custody.


In setting aside the election and ordering a fresh poll, the Court reaffirmed that an election petition is a special proceeding invoking the High Court’s original electoral jurisdiction under Article 86(1) of the Constitution and sections 79–82 of the Parliamentary Elections Act, and is distinct from the Court’s supervisory revisional jurisdiction;


Furthermore, that a recount under section 74 of the Act does not extinguish or replace the evidential value of the original polling-station Declaration of Results Forms, which remain relevant contemporaneous statutory records against which recount results must be evaluated;


The Court also clarified that the integrity of electoral materials depends not merely on the appearance of intact seals but on a properly documented and verifiable chain of custody, demonstrating that the materials presented for recount are the same materials secured at the close of polling; and fourth, that non-compliance with electoral law warrants setting aside an election where cogent evidence establishes that it substantially affected the result, as contemplated under section 80(1)(a) of the Act.


The Court further distinguished between proof of irregularities affecting the validity of an election and proof of personal criminal responsibility, finding that the Returning Officer’s failures in maintaining accountability records could attract the statutory consequences under section 97(g), without necessarily establishing that the 1st Respondent personally interfered with electoral materials.


Lastly, although the Court found that the recount-based declaration could not stand, it declined to declare the Petitioner the winner because the evidence did not safely establish that another candidate was duly elected; it therefore ordered a fresh election.


FACTS

The dispute arose from the parliamentary election for Buwekula South Constituency, Mubende District, in which Mubangizi Dedan, the 1st Respondent, was declared the winner following a judicially supervised recount of votes.


On 16th January 2026, the Returning Officer, having added up the Declaration of Results (DR) Forms under section 77(1) PEA, declared the Petitioner elected. The Return Form (annexure TF3) recorded the following;

Candidate

Party

Votes (16th January 2026)

Tumwesigye Fred

Independent

8,804

Mubangizi Dedan

NRM

7,998

Sempiira Edward

NUP

1,915

Total valid votes

 

18,717

 

The margin was 806 votes.


The Court recorded that, on the Petitioner’s uncontroverted evidence before the Chief Magistrate, invalid votes were 379.


The recount application

It was noted that on 23rd January 2026 the 1st Respondent applied to the Chief Magistrate’s Court of Mubende for a recount under section 74 PEA, vide Miscellaneous Cause No. 02 of 2026. The Petitioner opposed the application. The 2nd and 3rd Respondents also opposed it, deposing through their Senior Legal Officer that the tallying had been transparent and lawful and that the application was a fishing expedition.


On 27th January 2026 the Chief Magistrate granted the recount. The record of the recount (annexure TF9) showed that 89 ballot boxes were brought from the Electoral Commission stores at Mubende.


Before any box was opened, counsel for the Petitioner asked for the record of the serial numbers of the seals affixed at the close of polling. The Returning Officer told the court that he could not say what those numbers were.


The Chief Magistrate declined the request, directed that counting begin, and observed that if a box was opened and found to have issues, that would be a matter for an election petition and not for that court.


At the close of the recount on 28th January 2026, the Chief Magistrate issued a Certificate of Vote Recount (annexure TF13):

Candidate

DR Forms (16 Jan)

Recount

Change

Tumwesigye Fred

8,804

7,504

−1,300

Mubangizi Dedan

7,998

7,908

−90

Sempiira Edward

1,915

1,879

−36

Total valid votes

18,717

17,291

−1,426

 

Acting on the certificate, the 1st Respondent was declared elected, with a margin of 404 votes, and gazetted in the Uganda Gazette of 4th March 2026 (annexure TF14). The Court observed that the certificate records Sempiira’s total as 1,879 and not 1,878.


The revision proceedings

The Petitioner unsuccessfully sought revision of the recount in Tumwesigye Fred v Mubangizi Dedan and Others, Civil Revision No. 01 of 2026, [2026] UGHC 79 (14th February 2026), before Teko J.


The decision upheld the exercise of the Chief Magistrate’s jurisdiction but, as the Court in this Petition read it, distinguished the evidential significance of the ballots once the seals were opened and left such questions open to an election petition under section 80 PEA.


Dissatisfied with the decision revision the Petitioner Petitioned the High Court

The Petition was filed on 2nd April 2026, within thirty days of the gazettement of 4th March 2026, and no objection was taken to its timelines. It was brought under Articles 1(1) and (4), 59(1), 61(1)(d) and 68(1) of the Constitution; sections 12 and 13 of the Electoral Commission Act, Cap. 176; sections 71, 79, 80, 81, 82 and 83 of the PEA; and Rule 4 of the Parliamentary Elections (Election Petitions) Rules.


The Petitioner’s case, pleaded in paragraphs 8 to 17 of the Petition, was that the recount was conducted on electoral materials that had been interfered with while in the exclusive custody of the 2nd and 3rd Respondents between the close of polling and the recount.


He particularised the following;

  1. At Namalewe Life Centre Compound (Kyabaduuma) polling station, the ballot box held only unused ballot papers and partially used booklets, so that every vote cast there was missing.

  2. The seal serial numbers recorded by his polling agents at the close of polling differed from those found on the corresponding boxes at the recount.

  3. At 16 named polling stations, ballot papers were found outside the tamper-proof envelopes, and the envelopes were torn.

  4. At 12 further named polling stations, the tamper-proof envelopes were torn with ballots inside.

  5. At Nsengwe Trading Centre [MUC-Z], Buzooba Church Compound, Kayebe Health Centre II [A-MUH] and Kalonga A [A-NAKAM], ballots were found in zip-lock polythene bags, which are not official electoral materials.

  6. Voters’ registers were missing from some boxes.

  7. A polling-station comparison of DR Forms against recount figures (annexure TF11) showed discrepancies aggregating 1,392 votes, with the loss falling overwhelmingly on the Petitioner.


The Petitioner contended that these facts established non-compliance under section 80(1)(a) PEA that substantially affected the result. He prayed for

(a) a declaration that the 1st Respondent was not validly elected;

(b) a declaration that he was the duly elected Member of Parliament as declared on 16th January 2026;

(c) in the alternative, a fresh election; (d) a report to the Director of Public Prosecutions under section 82(8) PEA; and

(e) costs.


The Respondents’ answers

The 1st Respondent raised preliminary objections that the Petition disclosed no cause of action under section 80; that the reliefs sought were alien to the PEA; that the matters were res judicata by reason of Civil Revision No. 01 of 2026; that the Petition was a disguised appeal against that ruling; and that DR Forms are not applicable once a court-ordered recount has taken place.


On the merits, he averred that the Petitioner was irregularly declared on 16th January 2026 following counting and tallying errors; that the Chief Magistrate satisfied himself that all boxes were intact; that the Petitioner adduced no seal-number evidence at the recount; that the seal numbers now relied on were a fabrication; and that the recount reflected the free will of the voters.


The 2nd and 3rd Respondents, by their Answer and the affidavit of the Returning Officer, Mulekezi T. Ferdinand, raised the same objections of res judicata, no cause of action and disguised appeal. On the merits, they denied any tampering, averred that the seals remained intact, and pleaded in the alternative that any irregularities did not affect the result in a substantial manner.


The recount record (TF9) and the evidence at trial

The certified proceedings in Miscellaneous Cause No. 02 of 2026 comprise 68 pages and record the hearing before His Worship Ssajjabbi Noah Norobert, Chief Magistrate.


The Court recounted that the Chief Magistrate recorded that all 89 boxes and their visible seals were intact; that the Returning Officer could not provide a contemporaneous identification of the original seal numbers, and referred to his use of a replacement seal if a seal broke; and that the Chief Magistrate directed the recording of each visible seal number and the contents of each box.


When counsel sought to stop the count at several stations on account of loose ballots, torn packaging and absent DR Forms, the Chief Magistrate relied on the intact external seals, considered the Electoral Commission official’s explanation that some presiding officers did not use internal bags, and directed that counting continue with objections recorded.


The Court highlighted the following station entries in TF9, which featured in its analysis:

Polling station (TF9 item)

Fred: DR Form

Fred: recount

Condition recorded

Namalewe Life Centre Compound, Kyabaduuma (item 14)

179

No cast ballots

Seals EC1884405 and EC1884404; no DR Form and no cast ballots; 300 unused ballots and seven used booklets; inference of 350 missing parliamentary ballots

Sala C.O.U (item 7)

145

95

Ballots sealed in EC polythene; DR Forms inside

God’s Mercy Church (item 9)

45

25

Polling assistant’s oath, rather than ballots, sealed in the polythene bag

Butayunja Dam P/S, A-NATUJ (item 11)

88

59

Ballots in transparent zipped bag

Bright Angel P/S (item 16)

71

51

Internal plastic bags torn open

Kisenyi Stores, first entry (item 37)

135

94

Plastic bag open or torn

Kayebe Health Centre II, MUI-Z (item 36)

100 (agent’s evidence)

1

No DR Form; ballots outside bags; Dedan 145 on polling day against 147 at recount

Kitama P/S, A-MUG (item 32)

91

177

Plastic bag torn (an increase for the Petitioner)

 

At the trial, the Returning Officer was cross-examined on 6th October 2026, following the Court’s ruling in Miscellaneous Application No. 323 of 2026. It was noted that he accepted that he received and relied on the DR Forms and signed the original return.


On custody, he said there was no custody register, that he did not know how many seals had been supplied or whether all were used, and that there was no inventory of unused seals, the remaining seals having been returned to the office. He attended the recount only partially.


He agreed that interference with a tamper-proof envelope would leave traces, but answered negatively when asked whether a torn, cut, unsealed or opened envelope was compromised. He also accepted that, by the words “if any” in paragraph 6 of his affidavit, he had not positively sworn that no irregularity, tampering or omission had occurred. The Respondents declined to re-examine him.


When counsel sought to tender the affidavit of Mr. Kayondo Abubaker (filed in the revision proceedings) through him, the Respondents objected because he was not the deponent; the Court permitted cross-examination on the document but did not permit its tendering through this witness.


Proceedings before the Court

At the hearing of 23rd September 2026, the Respondents asked that the jurisdictional objection be disposed of before the pending applications and the merits. The Petitioner proposed that jurisdiction be framed as the first issue so that the Petition could be determined within its statutory timelines.


The Court directed that jurisdiction be resolved as an independent first issue in the main judgment, and the parties filed a Joint Scheduling Memorandum the same day, agreeing seven facts and framing five issues. After the Returning Officer testified, the Court directed the parties to abandon their earlier submissions and file afresh, the Petitioner by 8th October, the Respondents by 12th October and any rejoinder by 14th October 2026.


Issues for Determination

The Court recorded the following five issues from the Joint Scheduling Memorandum;

  1. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to adjudicate the Petition based on the grounds pleaded and declarations sought.

  2. Whether the additional affidavits in support of the Petition filed on 16th September 2026 are incurably defective. (The Court noted the 2nd and 3rd Respondents’ prayer, which it accepted, that the date be read as 26th and 27th August 2026.)

  3. Whether the 2nd and 3rd Respondents committed electoral offences under the Parliamentary Elections Act, Cap. 177.

  4. Whether the 1st Respondent is the validly elected Member of Parliament for Buwekula South Constituency.

  5. What remedies are available to the parties.


Legal Representation

Party

Representation

Petitioner (Tumwesigye Fred)

M/s Paul Sebunya & Co. Advocates, jointly with M/s J. Byamukama & Co. Advocates. Appearing: Mr. Paul Sebunya, Mr. Jude Byamukama, Mr. Innocent Idanobugo and Mr. Bugamba Blaise.

1st Respondent (Mubangizi Dedan)

M/s Alaka & Co. Advocates, jointly with M/s Ochieng Associated Advocates and Solicitors, M/s Magna Advocates and Sail Advocates. Appearing: Prof. Kyazze Joseph, Mr. Caleb Alaka, Mr. Ochieng Evans, Mr. Ronald Kwesiga and Mr. Audrien Kiryowa.

2nd Respondent (Electoral Commission) and 3rd Respondent (Returning Officer, Mubende)

M/s Mwesigwa Rukutana & Co. Advocates. Appearing: Mr. Mwesigwa Rukutana, SC.

 

The Petitioner and the 1st Respondent were present in Court, while the 2nd Respondent was represented by the 3rd Respondent, the Returning Officer for Mubende Electoral District.


BURDEN AND STANDARD OF PROOF IN ELECTION PETITIONS

The Court held that the burden of proof lies on the Petitioner, who must prove the grounds of his Petition to the satisfaction of the Court on a balance of probabilities, citing section 80(3) PEA and sections 101 to 103 of the Evidence Act, Cap. 8. It referred to Col. (Rtd) Dr. Kizza Besigye v Yoweri Kaguta Museveni & Electoral Commission, Presidential Election Petition No. 1 of 2001, and Amama Mbabazi v Yoweri Kaguta Museveni & 2 Others, Presidential Election Petition No. 1 of 2016, for the position that the burden rests squarely on the petitioner and that the court acts on evidence, not suspicion.


It was further held that because an election concerns the franchise of an entire constituency, the evidence must be cogent and the court left in no real doubt, but that this does not raise the standard above the civil one. The Court added that once a petitioner proves facts that call for an explanation lying peculiarly within the knowledge of the other side, the evidential burden shifts to that side, relying on section 106 of the Evidence Act.


SUBMISSIONS

Issue 1: Jurisdiction

For the Petitioner

Counsel submitted that Article 86(1) of the Constitution and sections 79 and 80 PEA conferred original jurisdiction to decide whether the 1st Respondent had been validly elected. It was maintained that the complaint concerned compromised materials and breach of the custodians’ statutory duties, rather than an appeal against the order permitting the recount.


Relying on Swaibu Senyonjo v Issa Nyombi, Civil Appeal No. 26 of 2017, Kasibante Moses v Katongole Singh Marwaha, Election Petition No. 23 of 2011, and Ogwari Polycarp v Ochwa David, Election Petition Appeal No. 004 of 2022, counsel argued that the validity question had not been finally decided in proceedings competent to determine that distinct issue. Counsel also relied on Teko J.’s express reference to a petition under section 80.


For the 1st Respondent

It was submitted that section 80 prescribes the permissible grounds for an election petition and does not authorise a further challenge to a judicial recount already upheld in revision. Relying on Hon. Piro Santos Eruaga v Gen. Moses Ali and Another and Faustine Ntambara v Benon Sebujisho, counsel argued that the parties, the subject matter, the complaints about seals and materials, and the relief of declaring the Petitioner elected had already featured in the recount and revision.


Counsel characterised Teko J.’s reference to a later petition as obiter that could not independently create jurisdiction, and submitted that this Court could not overturn another High Court Judge’s decision.


For the 2nd and 3rd Respondents

Counsel submitted that paragraphs 4 to 17 and prayers (a) and (b) of the Petition challenged the Chief Magistrate’s recount rather than non-compliance in the conduct of the election.

Invoking section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act and Eruaga, it was argued that integrity had already been examined before the recount and in revision, that the Petition was a disguised appeal, and that the statutory grounds could not be enlarged to permit a second recount challenge.


Relying on Order VI rules 28 and 29 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd in support of preliminary determination of those objections.


Regarding The additional affidavits

For the Petitioner, it was submitted that the September affidavits belonged to Applications Nos. 323 and 324, while the 94 additional affidavits in support of the Petition had been filed on 26th and 27th August 2026, before scheduling.


Counsel pointed to the 1st Respondent’s replying affidavit and Andrew Kiryowa’s affidavit filed on 9th September 2026 as showing an actual opportunity to respond, and relied on Tamale Julius Konde v Ssenkubuge Isaac and Another, Akugizibwe Lawrence v Muhumuza David and Another and Odo Tayebwa v Gordon Kakuuna Arinda and Another to urge that the evidence be received in the absence of demonstrated prejudice.


The 1st Respondent contended that the affidavits were filed without leave after the Respondents had exhausted their right of answer, although the information was available when the Petition was filed. Relying on Mutembuli Yusuf v Nagwomu Moses and the discussion in Konde, counsel argued that the later affidavits impermissibly repaired the Petition, prejudiced the defence and sought to reopen concluded recount matters.


The 2nd and 3rd Respondents objected that the affidavits repeated the same language, structure and conclusions, and that accounts derived from the Petitioner or a reading of the recount record were hearsay.


Relying on Order XIX rule 3, Kabusu Moses Wagaba v Lwanga Timothy Mutekanga and Dr. Bayiga Michael v Mutebi David and Another, they questioned the independence of the accounts and whether the record had been exhibited and translated for deponents unable to read it.


On the Electoral offences and validity of the election

For the Petitioner

Counsel submitted that the duties of safekeeping, inspection and documented resealing under section 71 were enforceable through section 97(g), and that the certified recount record (TF9) demonstrated failures that the custodians had not explained.


Relying on the missing cast ballots at Namalewe Life Centre Compound (Kyabaduuma), damaged internal packaging, missing statutory records and alleged changes in seal numbers.


Counsel invoked Electoral Commission and Iddi Isabirye v Robert Ntende in support of the Court’s power to make an election-offence finding concerning an official. It was further argued that the original 806-vote majority could not be displaced by the recount unless the materials recounted were reliable.


Counsel referred to the affidavit of Ssegawa Tonney and the DR Forms said to record 179 votes for the Petitioner, 131 for the 1st Respondent and 28 for Sempiira at Namalewe (Kyabaduuma), against the absence of cast ballots in that box at recount.


As a specific seal comparison, it was submitted that Kibyamirizi Primary School [A-M] had polling-day seals EC1884183, EC1884187, EC1884188 and EC1884186, whereas the recount recorded EC1884198 and EC1884197.


For the 1st Respondent

Counsel denied any breach of sections 71 or 97(g) and argued that an offence capable of setting aside his election under section 80(1)(c) had to be committed personally by him or with his knowledge and consent or approval, relying on Nabukeera Hussein Hanifah v Kusasira Peace K. Mubiru and Another and Bwino Fred Kyakulaga and Another v Badogi Ismail Waguma.


The Respondent submitted that the recount certificate superseded the DR Forms and earlier tally and was conclusive as to the valid votes, citing Ngoma Ngime v Hon. Winnie Byanyima, Election Petition Appeal No. 11 of 2002, Hon. Nantaba Idah Erios v Kabanda David for the corrective function of a recount, and the presumption of regularity under section 114 of the Evidence Act.


Counsel maintained that the initial declaration was affected by counting and tallying errors, that the judicially supervised recount established his 404-vote majority, and that the Petitioner had adduced no cogent evidence sufficient to displace it.


For the 2nd and 3rd Respondents

Counsel maintained that section 71 imposed a custodial duty rather than itself creating an offence, and that an official’s alleged omission did not, without the statutory requirements, annul the candidate’s election, relying on Sarah Bireete v Bomadatte and Electoral Commission.


Relying on the affidavit of Louis Mukiibi, it was submitted that the boxes were inspected at the Commission’s stores in the presence of the Chief Magistrate and counsel, found intact and transported for a peaceful recount. Counsel challenged reliance on Mr. Kayondo’s affidavit, disputing its attachment and his personal knowledge, and argued that legal officers’ statements could not substitute for evidence from the responsible custodians.


Remedies

The Petitioner sought a declaration that he was duly elected, an order requiring the 1st Respondent to vacate the seat and costs, with a fresh election pleaded in the alternative.


The 1st Respondent asked for dismissal with costs under section 82(4)(a), maintaining that no statutory ground had been pleaded or proved, and argued that the Petitioner could not both condemn the election and claim its benefit, invoking approbation and reprobation.


The 2nd and 3rd Respondents sought dismissal with costs, submitting that election remedies had to rest on proof rather than speculation.


THE COURT’S FINDINGS

Regarding the Jurisdiction, res judicata and cause of action

The Court observed that the objections on jurisdiction, res judicata, absence of a cause of action and abuse of process must be distinguished, and that it must respect any issue finally decided in earlier proceedings. It stated;

“The question is what was decided, not simply whether the same election and parties appeared before the courts previously.”

It held at the outset that the Revision ruling does not bar the Petition, because it was made in a different jurisdiction, on a different question, and expressly left the present questions to an election petition.


Two different jurisdictions

The Court held that it sits under Article 86(1) of the Constitution and sections 79 to 82 PEA, an original jurisdiction over the validity of the election itself, carrying power to receive evidence, order inspection, find facts, and declare who was duly elected or set the election aside.


The Revision court, by contrast, sat under section 83 of the Civil Procedure Act, a supervisory jurisdiction that asks only whether the magistrate had jurisdiction, failed to exercise it, or exercised it illegally or with material irregularity.


The Court noted that Teko J. was careful to caution himself against turning the revision into an appeal, adopting the statement of Mubiru J. in Gulu University v Planex Group of Companies Ltd, Misc. Application No. 0012 of 2022 that a revising court is concerned with due process and not the correctness of the findings below.


Regarding the statutory test of res judicata

Applying section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act and Mansukhlal Ramji Karia and Another v Attorney General and Others, Civil Appeal No. 20 of 2002, the Court accepted that identity of parties was present but held that the decisive inquiry was the identity and final determination of the particular issue relied upon as a bar.


The Court held that the Chief Magistrate did not try an election petition, and the High Court in revision did not exercise its original jurisdiction to determine the validity of a parliamentary election after a trial under Part X of the PEA.


The Court also noted that the revision ruling preceded the gazettement of 4th March 2026, but observed that this was not a complete answer to issue estoppel, the more substantial answer being that the ruling distinguished the magistrate’s numerical function from the evidential value of the ballots after opening and expressly recognised the availability of a petition under section 80.


The Court was careful to delimit what it would not revisit. It rejected any invitation to reopen the competence of the recount application, the discretion to order it, the admissibility of the affidavit used in that application, or the decision that a comprehensive reconciliation was not mandatory as part of the Chief Magistrate’s numerical exercise. Of the revision ruling, it stated;

“Its dismissal cannot be ignored; neither can its express reservation of questions for petition adjudication.”


Hon. Piro Santos Eruaga v Gen. Moses Ali and Another, Election Petition No. 001 of 2011 was distinguished. The Court accepted that the decision demonstrates that a petition cannot merely repackage numerical questions already determined in competent recount proceedings, but held that here the pleaded complaint was that the material later counted had not been preserved and that the resulting declaration was substantially affected.


The questions reserved for the petition

Reviewing TF9 pages 14 to 15, the Court accepted as a fact the Chief Magistrate’s observation of physical intactness of the boxes, but held that the remaining question was whether, in light of the whole evidence, the contents were sufficiently authenticated to support the later declaration. It added a point of principle on jurisdiction;

“jurisdiction does not arise from counsel’s concessions or inconsistent arguments. It arises from the Constitution and the Act.”

The statute contemplates a petition after a recount

The Court held that section 67(3) PEA makes a presiding officer’s decision on a disputed ballot final subject to reversal only on recount or on a petition questioning the election return, and that neither section 74 (recount) nor section 77(4) (declaration upon receipt of the recount certificate) excludes section 80 or the High Court’s jurisdiction under Article 86(1).


It reasoned that a valid recount ordinarily displaces an erroneous earlier tally, but that this proposition does not make the materials counted immune from proof of compromised custody in a properly constituted petition.


Cause of action and the status of DR Forms

Paragraphs 8 to 17 of the Petition were held to plead failure to preserve electoral materials, specific discrepancies and substantial effect on the result under section 80(1)(a), and the prayer that the Petitioner be declared elected engaged section 80(1)(b).


The Court held that the claim “may succeed or fail on proof, but it is not devoid of a statutory cause of action”, drawing support from Kasibante Moses v Katongole Singh Marwaha, [2011] UGHC 153.


As to DR Forms, it was held that they do not cease to be evidence because a recount occurred, remaining contemporaneous statutory records under sections 66 and 69 to be weighed against the ballots and other records, and that section 75(1) on costs where a recount changes the result creates no rule excluding them from a later petition.


Holding on Issue 1 

The Petition falls within the Court’s electoral jurisdiction and the preliminary objections were overruled, subject to the limits stated concerning issues already finally determined.


Regarding The additional affidavits

The Court addressed the August affidavits, to which both sides had substantively spoken. It held that Rule 4(8) of the Parliamentary Elections (Election Petitions) Rules requires a supporting affidavit and list of documents with the Petition, but that this is not a requirement that every witness affidavit be filed on the same day, and also does not permit new grounds to be introduced after the statutory filing period under the description of additional evidence.


Relying on Tamale Julius Konde v Ssenkubuge Isaac and Another, Election Petition Appeal No. 75 of 2016, [2017] UGCA 166, the Court noted that the Court of Appeal accepted pre-scheduling additional affidavits where adverse parties could respond without injustice, as distinct from evidence filed after scheduling, for which leave should be sought.


The impugned affidavits preceded the scheduling of 23rd September 2026, addressed custody and discrepancies already pleaded, and were in fact answered by the 1st Respondent in September. No particular new ground or irremediable prejudice had been identified. Mutembuli Yusuf v Nagwomu Moses Musamba and Another was applied only for its caution against using further affidavits to introduce fresh matters after the opponent’s answer.


The Court then drew a firm line between admissibility and weight. It held that under Order XIX rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules a trial affidavit must be confined to facts the deponent can prove from personal knowledge, and it refused to accept an agent’s account of a recount which the agent did not attend as independent eyewitness proof of that recount.


The Court stated that TF9 is the evidence of what the Chief Magistrate recorded, and that the agents’ direct evidence is relevant to their own polling stations, the counts they witnessed, the forms they signed and any packaging they personally observed. On the objection about common wording, it observed;

“professionally drafted repetition is not independent corroboration.”

Similar language, it held, does not erase a witness’s personal presence at a count, while a shared conclusion about subsequent theft attracts no additional weight merely because many witnesses repeat it. On the objection concerning illiterate deponents, the Court examined the jurats, including that of Biryomumeisho Gad recording reading and explanation in Runyankore, and found that the general assertion that every such affidavit lacked explanation was not established, while noting that a jurat does not cure hearsay about an unwitnessed recount.

Holding on Issue 2

This issue was answered in the negative. The additional affidavits are not collectively incurably defective, and only their admissible, probative contents were used.


Regarding The Electoral offences by the 2nd and 3rd Respondents

The Court explained that section 71 PEA imposes personal responsibility on the Returning Officer for safekeeping, examination of seals upon receipt, and recording and resealing a box found not in good order, and that section 97(g) makes it an offence for an election officer or other person with an election duty, without reasonable cause, to act or omit to act in breach of that duty. It cautioned that the absence of reasonable cause is part of the statutory inquiry and that;

“an offence must not be inferred merely because a disputed count later differs.”

The Court rejected the Respondents’ contention that only an offence attributable to the candidate under section 80(1)(c) can invalidate an election, holding that this conflates separate grounds.


Personal commission, or knowledge and consent or approval, is necessary only where section 80(1)(c) is invoked against the candidate. Non-compliance by election officials can independently engage section 80(1)(a), provided substantial effect is proved, and section 80(1)(b) addresses a different person having won. Section 97(g) is directed to persons performing election duties and cannot reasonably be read as exempting the Returning Officer.


Relying on Iddi Isabirye and Electoral Commission v Ntende Robert, Consolidated Election Petition Appeals Nos. 60 and 64 of 2021 was read narrowly. The Court noted that the Court of Appeal sustained the finding concerning wrong returns by election officials while distinguishing it from the candidate-specific ground for invalidation, and that the appeal ultimately restored the candidate’s election. It therefore declined to treat that decision as holding that an official’s offence automatically voids an election.


On the evidence, the Court found serious failures of electoral safekeeping. It noted that the Returning Officer’s inability to produce a custody register or unused-seal inventory, and his limited presence at the recount, weakened his blanket assurance of preservation. That the absence of a register by that name is not itself a statutory offence; the material failure was the lack of a satisfactory account of the missing cast ballots and of the preservation and identification of the challenged boxes, for which no reasonable explanation was given.


The Court was satisfied that the 3rd Respondent’s unexplained omission to discharge the safekeeping duty falls within section 97(g), but specified that:

“It is not a finding that he personally removed particular ballots, replaced a particular seal, or acted at the direction of the 1st Respondent.”

Institutional responsibility for the established non-compliance was placed on the 2nd Respondent, though corporate criminal responsibility is not inferred solely from the acts or omissions of an unidentified employee.


Noting that section 82(7) withholds power to convict in an election petition, but section 82(8) requires a written report naming the person and the nature of the offence considered proved, the Court directed a report identifying Mulekezi T. Ferdinand and the official omission under section 97(g). It emphasised that the setting aside of the 1st Respondent’s declaration “does not depend on personal guilt on his part”.


Holding on Issue 3 

The third Issue was answered in the affirmative in a limited respect against the 3rd Respondent; institutional non-compliance was established against the 2nd Respondent.


Whether the 1st Respondent was validly elected

The Court stated that it would determine the issue by examining the authentication of the materials recounted, the resulting discrepancies, their effect on the declared outcome, and the affirmative evidence of who won, and acknowledged that a recount certificate carries statutory significance such that the Petitioner must establish a substantial evidential basis for departing from it.


The Court summarised the custody framework as follows;

Provision

Duty

Purpose (as the Court described it)

s. 47(2)(b)

Commission to give candidates the serial numbers of seals affixed to and enclosed in each box, not later than 24 hours before polling

Candidates can later check that the seals are the originals

s. 47(3)

Any replacement of a seal to be documented by the presiding officer and witnessed by agents

No seal changes hands unrecorded

ss. 66(5)-(7), 69(1)

DR Form completed and signed by presiding officer; agents may sign; signed form retained in the box

A contemporaneous, multi-party record of the count

s. 69(2)

Box sealed in the presence of candidates and agents

Agents witness the seal

s. 69(4)

Box to contain DR Form, bundled candidates’ ballots, invalid, spoilt and unused ballots, voters roll and report book

Every item needed to reconcile the box is inside it

s. 71(1)-(2)

Returning Officer responsible for safe custody; to examine each seal on receipt and, if not in order, record observations and affix a new seal

Any break in custody is recorded

 

The Court clarified that section 47 is a pre-poll disclosure provision and must not be misdescribed as expressly requiring a fresh list twenty-four hours after polling or a separate certificate of integrity before a recount. Its purpose continues to matter when the boxes are later opened, because the seals supplied and any documented replacements provide a basis for checking authenticity. It added that a lawful replacement under section 71(2)(c) is possible, but the observations requiring it must be recorded, and that:

“Different numbers are therefore a matter requiring inquiry and explanation, not automatic proof of fraud in every case.”

The chain of custody was not proved

The Court acknowledged that TF9 pages 14 to 15, recording the parties’ agreement that the visible seals were intact and the Chief Magistrate’s corresponding observation, was “important evidence in the Respondents’ favour”. It nonetheless held that the Chief Magistrate’s direction to record the visible numbers preserved the numbers then seen but did not establish that they were the post-poll seals or documented lawful replacements.

The Court drew the central distinction of the judgment;

“The distinction is between physical condition at inspection and continuity of identity from polling. An unbroken seal may be original or a replacement.”

What excludes an unauthorised replacement, it held, is credible traceability, including the section 47 records, a documented replacement where applicable, or reliable evidence explaining the box’s custody. No satisfactory record reconciling the challenged seals and custody had been produced, and the Returning Officer’s trial answers concerning the absence of custody records and unused-seal inventory materially weakened reliance on appearance alone.


The Court weighed in on the Petitioner’s seal allegations. It declined to treat an allegation, or a comparison recited only in submissions, as a proved station-by-station schedule, and declined to infer that all 89 boxes were opened merely because the original seal lists were unavailable. Its finding was narrower;

“the integrity of the challenged materials was not established by the assertion of intact visible seals”

together with the recorded internal defects and numerical losses, which provided affirmative evidence making that omission material.


The contents recorded at the recount

The Court observed that section 69(4) does not itself use the expression “tamper-proof envelope” as a condition rendering every loose ballot invalid, and that the evidential question is whether the condition found, weighed against the evidence of packing and the numerical records, supports confidence in unchanged contents. It then reviewed TF9 examples;

  1. At Namalewe (Kyabaduuma), item 14. 

    The seals were present, but no DR Form and no cast ballots, only 300 unused ballot papers and seven used booklets. The Court stressed that this is distinct from the other Namalewe entry (items at pages 52 to 53) which contained ballots, and refused to transfer one box’s defect to the other. It held that “A complete absence of those ballots is not a counting correction.”


  2. Answered Prayers P/S, Bugalaja B. 

    The unfilled DR Forms and broken seals inside. The Court declined to treat broken enclosed seals as proof of illicit entry, since they may legitimately have been broken in the polling-day count, and relied instead on the missing completed record in context.


  3. Kagoma P/S [A-NAKAS]

    The ballots in EC-marked polythene but no DR Form, proving a departure from required contents but not, by itself, who caused it or when.


  4. Zip-lock bags

    The Court refused to hold that the description alone makes ballots spurious; the question is whether the packaging corresponds to what was supplied and used, and whether any change is satisfactorily explained.


  5. Loose ballots and torn packaging. 

    The Electoral Commission official’s explanation that some presiding officers did not use the bags may explain initially loose ballots at some stations, but does not explain a missing completed DR Form, a box without cast ballots, or a material reduction in candidate totals where direct polling evidence supports the original count.


  6. Missing voters’ rolls. 

    These bear upon the ability to verify participation, but the Petition “is not decided by counting the number of allegations. Relying on Byanyima Winnie v Ngoma Ngime, Civil Revision No. 9 of 2001, [2001] UGHC 92, and Bagoole John Ngobi v Kyobe Luke Inyensiko, Miscellaneous Cause No. 6 of 2016, [2016] UGHC 5, were cited as recognising the need for secured materials if a recount is to serve its purpose. The Court noted they were not factually identical, since visible seals here were unbroken, and applied the principle of reliability of materials without substituting a finding of broken external seals which TF9 does not support.


(d) The numerical discrepancies

The Court computed the reduction of 1,426 valid votes and its distribution:

Candidate

Share of DR valid votes

Votes lost at recount

Share of the loss

Tumwesigye Fred

47.0%

1,300

91.2%

Mubangizi Dedan

42.7%

90

6.3%

Sempiira Edward

10.2%

36

2.5%

Total

100%

1,426

100%

 

It was noted that a difference between a DR Form and a recount does not itself prove removal, since lawful reclassification and correction of arithmetic can cause differences.


The Court therefore tested that explanation against the aggregates. Invalid ballots fell from 379 to 190, so that invalidation of previously valid ballots could not explain the disappearance of 1,426 valid votes; the combined valid and invalid total fell from 19,096 to 17,481, a reduction of 1,615.


The TF11 figure of 1,392 was held to be a different calculation and was not presented as an exact reconciliation. The Court treated the 91.2% distribution as follows:

“That distribution is corroborative; it is not a statistical demonstration of fraud.”

The Court relied on the box without cast ballots and on station-specific evidence, including Biryomumeisho Gad’s direct polling evidence for Kayebe Health Centre II [MUI-Z] recording 100 votes for the Petitioner and 145 for the 1st Respondent against recount entries of 1 and 147.


The Court stressed that it relied on TF9 for the recount and on the agent’s personal observation and attached forms for the earlier count, and not on his opinion about who removed ballots.


The Court held that the 2nd and 3rd Respondents were required to address those concrete inconsistencies. Their explanation that the recount corrected numerical errors did not identify a corresponding erroneous allocation of 1,300 votes to the Petitioner on polling day or account for the absent cast ballots, and the Returning Officer supplied no custody evidence explaining the losses.


Conclusion on the reliability of the recount

On a balance of probabilities, the Court found established that (i) the authentication and safekeeping of the challenged electoral materials were not satisfactorily demonstrated in accordance with sections 47, 69, 70 and 71 PEA; (ii) the absence of cast ballots from the Namalewe (Kyabaduuma) box, other recorded defects and unexplained numerical losses established material compromise of the recount evidence; and (iii) while the evidence did not establish the identity of every person responsible or prove that every box was interfered with, it did establish that:

“the recount certificate is unreliable as the basis for displacing the original result in this election.”

The Court refused to consider the certificate as evidence of the electorate's votes. It emphasized that it was not reviewing Teko J.'s decision, was not revisiting the reasons for ordering the recount, and was not asserting that the Chief Magistrate lacked jurisdiction. The material irregularity was solely related to "the unverified continuity and compromised condition of the materials."


The Court held that section 77(4) does not place the declaration beyond examination under sections 80 and 82, and read Kasibante as supporting the proposition that a recount’s outcome does not conclusively settle the separate statutory question of valid election, without transposing its facts of unlawful delegation and disobedience of an interim order.


Non-compliance and substantial effect under section 80(1)(a)

The Court recognised that section 80(1)(a) requires proof both of non-compliance and that it affected the result in a substantial manner, and that:

“Neither an absent internal bag nor a missing form, considered in isolation, automatically invalidates an election.”

It found, however, that missing DR Forms were not confined to Namalewe but were recorded at dozens of stations, which it listed by name, including Answered Prayers Bugalaja B, Kagoma A-NAKAS, Angel Gabriel, Saka, both Buwekula Parents entries, Kyambogo Bright Star, Katoma Pentecostal Church, Njagaazi at Ndagi Tree, Kitaama MUH-Z, Kibyamirizi A-M, Butayunja Erim Church, Kayebe Health Centre II MUI-Z and Nsengwe MUC-Z, among others.


The Court cautioned that a missing box copy of a DR Form does not prove that an agent’s copy or the Returning Officer’s separately held copy is false or unavailable, nor does it by itself prove removal of ballots. Its significance was that it deprived the recount of the contemporaneous box record against which contents and differences could be checked.


On the station figures, the Court noted reductions for the Petitioner from 145 to 95 at Sala C.O.U, 45 to 25 at God’s Mercy Church, 88 to 59 at Butayunja Dam A-NATUJ, 71 to 51 at Bright Angel, 57 to 47 at Nsengwe A-MUG, 69 to 49 at Kibuye A-MUKAM, 135 to 94 at Kisenyi Stores, 113 to 92 at Buzoba and 61 to 38 at Kayebe Health Centre II A-MUH.


These were described as documented differences which, without an explanation or reliable continuity of custody, could not all be assumed to be lawful corrections, though equally they did not establish the precise number physically removed. The Court was even-handed in noting that Kitama A-MUG recorded an increase for the Petitioner from 91 to 177, and that express reclassifications at Kyakadali and other stations showed genuine correction was possible and must be distinguished from unexplained losses.


On substantial effect, the Court noted that the missing ballots at Namalewe could not alone be taken as numerically sufficient to reverse the margin, their importance being direct proof of a failure affecting the available electoral material, considered with the other differences and custody evidence. It observed that an original lead of 806 for the Petitioner became a lead of 404 for the 1st Respondent, a net movement of 1,210, and that the unexplained loss from the Petitioner’s recorded total exceeded the original margin. It concluded;

“The failures in authentication and preservation went to the very materials used to change the declared winner”

and, on a balance of probabilities, held section 80(1)(a) proved, without attributing personal interference to the 1st Respondent or treating every box as compromised.


Whether another candidate can safely be declared elected

The Court accepted that the original return (TF3) and the polling-day DR Forms were substantial evidence in the Petitioner’s favour, and that the parties’ agreement in the Joint Scheduling Memorandum established the historical declaration, but not that the Petitioner was necessarily the lawful winner.

It held that the failure of the recount does not, without a further evidential finding, prove every figure in the original return, because the competing records include discrepancies in both directions and lawful reclassifications. In the absence of the relevant ballots and completed box records, it could not derive a complete corrected tally from authenticated station evidence.


It stated plainly;

“Nor can the Court fill the evidential gaps by awarding missing votes to either candidate.”

The Court was therefore satisfied that the recount-based declaration of the 1st Respondent cannot stand, but not that the record safely establishes another candidate’s entitlement. The additional ground in section 80(1)(b) was not proved to the extent required for a declaration in the Petitioner’s favour under section 82(4)(b).


Regarding A fresh election

Drawing on Articles 1(1) and (4), 59(1), 61(1), 68(1) and 126(1) of the Constitution, the Court held that these inform the application of sections 80 and 82 but do not relieve the Petitioner of the statutory burden or authorise the Court to choose a representative for the constituency. It observed that the voters’ will is expressed not merely by attending the poll but through the faithful recording, preservation, counting and declaration of their votes, and that:

“The Court must protect the voters’ actual choice, rather than presume which candidate the unavailable materials would have supported.”

The Court acknowledged that a fresh election requires citizens who already voted to vote again, but held that burden justified by the proved statutory ground and the inability to identify a reliable winner. It described the remedy in these terms:

“it returns the choice of representative to the electorate where the available record cannot safely settle it.”


Section 80(2), section 82(4)(c) and section 82(6)(c) PEA were identified as the applicable provisions. The Court added that another recount under section 82(5) “would not restore missing ballots or missing contemporaneous records” and would repeat the same unresolved evidential problem.


Holding on Issue 4 

The Court held that the 1st Respondent was not validly elected, his election is set aside under section 80(1)(a), and no other candidate is declared elected on this record.


Remedies

The Court held that the appropriate remedy is to set aside the 1st Respondent’s election and order a fresh election as if it were a by-election, under sections 80(2), 82(4)(c) and 82(6)(c) read with section 3 PEA.


The seat is declared vacant, and the Registrar is to forward a certified copy of the determination to the Clerk to Parliament and the Electoral Commission. The Petitioner’s primary prayer to be declared elected was declined, while his alternative prayer for a fresh election was granted.


The Electoral Commission is to arrange and conduct the fresh election, and the Court clarified that the order concerns the constituency election and is not confined to a fresh poll in the particular stations where defects were recorded.


On the report to the DPP, the Court held that the Registrar shall transmit the written report required by section 82(8), identifying Mulekezi T. Ferdinand and the omission in breach of official duty under section 97(g), with the judgment and record. It stated that section 82(7) precludes conviction in the Petition and that it makes no finding identifying the person who actually removed or altered particular materials.


On costs, exercising its discretion under section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act, the Court awarded the Petitioner the costs of the Petition against all three Respondents, reasoning that the 1st Respondent defended the declaration now set aside, while the 2nd and 3rd Respondents’ established failures concerned the very materials which generated it.


FINAL ORDERS

The Court entered judgment for the Petitioner and made the following orders;

  1. The preliminary objections of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents that the Petition is res judicata, an abuse of court process, a disguised appeal against the ruling in Civil Revision No. 01 of 2026, and discloses no cause of action, are overruled.

  2. The Petition succeeds under section 80(1)(a) of the Parliamentary Elections Act, Cap. 177.

  3. The 1st Respondent, Mubangizi Dedan, was not validly elected Member of Parliament for Buwekula South Constituency, Mubende District. His declaration following the recount, and the publication of his name in the Uganda Gazette of 4th March 2026, are set aside.

  4. The Certificate of Vote Recount dated 28th January 2026 does not reliably establish the final result for purposes of the Petition and cannot sustain the 1st Respondent’s election.

  5. The prayer to declare the Petitioner duly elected is declined. No other candidate is declared entitled to the seat on the available evidence.

  6. A fresh election for the directly elected Member of Parliament for Buwekula South Constituency shall be held as if it were a by-election, in accordance with sections 3, 80(2), 82(4)(c) and 82(6)(c) PEA, subject to the applicable constitutional and statutory requirements.

  7. The seat is declared vacant. The Registrar shall forthwith forward the certified copy of the determination to the Clerk to Parliament and the Electoral Commission under section 82(6)(c).

  8. The 1st Respondent shall vacate the seat forthwith. Nothing in the judgment affects the validity of any proceedings of Parliament in which he took part.

  9. The Registrar shall transmit a copy of the judgment to the Director of Public Prosecutions for such investigation as may be necessary concerning the custody and handling of the Buwekula South electoral materials between 15th January 2026 and 28th January 2026, and the DPP shall report the findings to the Court within fifteen (15) days from receipt of the judgment, for further directions.

  10. For the avoidance of doubt, the Court makes no finding of criminal liability against any individual, and nothing in the judgment shall be construed as a conviction or determination of criminal responsibility.

The 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents shall jointly and severally pay the Petitioner’s costs of the Petition


Read the full decision


Comments


LEAVE A REPLY

Thanks for submitting!

Writing in Notepad

Write for Us

Appointing New Writers

We're actively seeking passionate researchers and writers to join our team. If you're enthusiastic about sharing knowledge and contributing to our platform, we'd love to hear from you. Don't hesitate to apply – your expertise could make a significant impact on our community's learning experience.

Green Modern Real Estate Agent Linkedin Banner (1).jpg

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Be the first to know about our events, conferences, workshops, live training and consultations.

SUCCESSFULLY SUBSCRIBED!

Green Modern Real Estate Agent Linkedin Banner.jpg
bottom of page