top of page

High Court Orders DNA Sibling Kinship Test to Establish Biological Relationship Between Two Women in a Land Dispute; Reaffirms Court's Inherent Jurisdiction to Facilitate Scientific Investigations.

Nov 7
17 min read

High Court Orders DNA Sibling Kinship Test to Establish Biological Relationship Between Two Women in a Land Dispute; Reaffirms Court's Inherent Jurisdiction to Facilitate Scientific Investigations, Subject to Privacy, Dignity, and Bodily Integrity


Snapshot

In this case, the High Court considered whether it could order DNA sibling kinship testing where the existence of a biological relationship between two parties was disputed but directly affected their competing proprietary claims over land.


The Applicant sought to establish whether she and the Respondent shared the same biological mother, a question relevant to her claim to an interest in the disputed land as a descendant and beneficiary of the deceased.


The Court held that it has inherent jurisdiction under section 98 of the Civil Procedure Act, read together with section 37 of the Judicature Act, to facilitate DNA testing where biological relationships are genuinely disputed and material to the determination of a case. However, such testing is not automatic: the Court must be satisfied that the proposed test addresses a genuine and material issue, that the application is made in good faith, and that the evidential value of the test justifies the intrusion into the participants’ rights to privacy, dignity and bodily integrity under Articles 27 and 24 of the Constitution.


The Court further clarified that the absence of birth certificates or supporting affidavits from other relatives does not, by itself, bar an application for DNA testing, nor does the absence of a rejoinder automatically amount to an admission of the opposing party’s averments.


It also emphasised that scientific testing must be capable of producing evidence relevant to the question before the Court and that less intrusive methods should be preferred over measures such as exhumation.


Accordingly, the Court ordered sibling kinship testing at the Government Analytical Laboratory, subject to safeguards protecting the parties’ rights, and held that the resulting report would assist in resolving the substantive issues in the main suit.


FACTS OF THE CASE

The Applicant, Nandutu Harriet, instituted Miscellaneous Application No. 2559 of 2025 against the Respondent, Adeke Sarah, seeking an order of court directing that a DNA test, in the form of a sibling kinship test, be conducted on both parties to establish whether they were uterine sisters, that is, whether they shared the same biological mother.


The application arose from Civil Suit No. 779 of 2025, in which the Applicant had instituted proceedings against the Respondent and three other defendants concerning land comprised in Kyadondo Block 229 Plot 2693 at Kamuli. The Applicant claimed an interest in the disputed property as a beneficiary of the estate of the late Veria Nakanyike.


The Applicant's claim was premised, among other things, on her assertion that she and the Respondent were daughters of the late Namuyingo Eroni, who was herself a daughter of the late Veria Nakanyike. According to the Applicant, the late Namuyingo Eroni was survived by three children, namely, the late Kizito Edward, the Respondent and the Applicant.


The Applicant contended that the Respondent's denial of their alleged biological relationship in her written statement of defence in the main suit had placed their kinship directly in issue. She maintained that establishing their biological relationship was necessary because it would assist the Court in determining whether she had a legitimate interest in the disputed family land.


In her supporting affidavit, the Applicant further averred that the Respondent's two children, Tonny and Joshua, were in her maintenance and custody. She also alleged that the Respondent had transacted with third parties in respect of the family land without involving the other beneficiaries. She maintained that the application had been brought in good faith and was neither intended to embarrass nor economically exploit the Respondent.


The Respondent opposed the application, vehemently denying that the Applicant was her sister. She stated that she had never known or encountered the Applicant during the lifetime of her mother, whom she identified as the late Namiyingo Hellen, or her grandmother, the late Nakanyike Veria. She further denied knowing anyone by the name Namuyingo Eroni, whom the Applicant alleged was their common mother.


The Respondent contended that the Applicant had only emerged after the death of her brother, Kizito Edward, in 2016. She also denied having sons named Tonny and Joshua, maintaining that she had four children, all girls, who lived with her.


The Respondent characterised the application as an attempt by the Applicant to manufacture a family relationship in order to acquire an interest in the disputed land. She further contended that the property had been transferred to her in 2005 during the lifetime of her grandmother and was therefore not part of the estate as alleged by the Applicant. In support of her position, she attached a copy of the title to the land.


The Respondent also relied on a judgment in Kalisa Angelo & Another v Nandutu Harriet, Civil Suit No. 004 of 2024, in which, according to her, the Applicant had been declared a trespasser. She alleged that the Applicant was collecting rent from the property and using part of it as her residence, and that the present application was intended to frustrate persons who had purchased interests in the land.


In the alternative, the Respondent proposed that, should the Court find DNA testing necessary, the remains of her late mother should be exhumed to establish whether the Applicant was her biological child.


It was against this background that the Applicant approached the High Court seeking an order facilitating DNA testing between the parties.


ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

The Court identified the following issues for determination:

1. Whether the Applicant had established sufficient grounds to warrant an order for DNA testing to determine whether she and the Respondent were uterine sisters.

2. What remedies, if any, were available to the parties.


LEGAL REPRESENTATION

The Applicant was represented by Mr. Ibrahim Katongole of Malik Advocates.

Following substituted service, the Respondent appeared in Court and informed the Court that she did not have legal representation in the application.


However, Counsel for the Applicant informed Court that the Respondent was represented by T. Odeke & Co. Advocates in the substantive civil suit. He further informed Court that he had served Counsel Martin Mututa of the said law firm with the application on 13th August 2026, who had undertaken to inform the Respondent accordingly.


SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES

Applicant's submissions

Counsel for the Applicant submitted that the Respondent's affidavit in reply amounted to a general denial and did not substantially controvert the grounds upon which the application was founded.


It was submitted that the question of whether the parties shared a common biological mother was central to the determination of the substantive land dispute. Counsel maintained that the Applicant's claim to an interest in the disputed property depended, among other things, on establishing her biological relationship with the Respondent and their alleged common ancestry.


Counsel further argued that DNA testing would provide an effective scientific means of resolving the contested question of kinship and would assist Court in determining the parties' respective claims in the main suit.


On the basis of the foregoing, Counsel urged Court to grant the application and direct that a DNA sibling kinship test be conducted to establish whether the Applicant and Respondent shared the same biological mother.


Respondent's submissions

In opposition, the Respondent submitted that the Applicant had failed to establish a sufficient factual basis to justify the proposed DNA examination.


It was argued that the Applicant had not presented documentary or independent evidence to corroborate the alleged biological relationship. In particular, the Respondent contended that the Applicant had failed to produce birth certificates, family records or affidavits from other relatives capable of supporting her assertion that the parties were daughters of the same mother.


The Respondent further submitted that the Applicant's failure to file an affidavit in rejoinder meant that the specific factual allegations contained in the affidavit in reply had remained unanswered.


Counsel also argued that the application was not genuinely intended to establish a biological relationship but was instead an attempt to advance the Applicant's claim to the disputed land.


The Respondent accordingly prayed that the application be dismissed with costs.


COURT'S FINDINGS AND DETERMINATION

In determining the application, the High Court considered the circumstances under which it could exercise its jurisdiction to facilitate DNA testing in civil proceedings, particularly where the proposed examination concerned the biological relationship between two adults who did not consent to the test.


Court's jurisdiction to order DNA testing in civil proceedings

The Court observed that the question before it was not whether the Applicant had already established that she and the Respondent shared the same biological mother, but whether she had presented sufficient evidence to justify the Court facilitating the scientific examination intended to resolve that very question.


In considering its jurisdiction, the Court relied on section 98 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap. 282, which preserves the inherent powers of Court to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of its process. The Court also referred to section 37 of the Judicature Act, Cap. 16.


The Court emphasised that these provisions did not create an automatic entitlement to DNA testing but provided a jurisdiction that had to be exercised judiciously, taking into account the nature of the dispute, the relevance of the proposed evidence and the rights of the persons required to participate.


In this regard, the Court held;

"These provisions do not, by themselves, create an automatic entitlement to DNA testing. They provide a jurisdiction which must be exercised judiciously, having regard to the nature of the dispute, the relevance of the proposed evidence and the rights of the persons who would be required to participate."

The Court further noted that an order for DNA testing had to be considered alongside the constitutional protection of privacy and human dignity under Articles 27 and 24 of the Constitution, respectively.


It was observed that the collection and analysis of genetic material constituted an intrusion into a person's bodily and information privacy. Consequently, Court could not grant such an order merely because one party considered DNA testing desirable.


The Court explained that it had to be satisfied that the proposed examination was intended to establish a genuine and material question, that the application had been brought in good faith and that the intrusion was justified by the interests of justice.

The Court stated;

"The taking and analysis of a person's genetic material is an intrusion into one's bodily and information privacy."

It further held that;

"The Court must be satisfied that the proposed examination is directed at determining a genuine and material question; that the Application is brought in good faith; and that the intrusion is justified by the interests of justice."

The applicable principles governing DNA testing and biological kinship disputes

The Court considered several previous decisions addressing DNA testing and the establishment of biological relationships.


First, it considered Sserunjogi Charles Musoke & Another v Tony Nkuubi, Originating Summons No. 07 of 2019, [2019] UGHCFD 43, in which the High Court considered a request for DNA testing in a dispute concerning the biological relationship between a defendant and a deceased person whose estate was the subject of the proceedings.


The Court noted that the decision recognised that DNA testing could be appropriate where a biological relationship was material to the determination of legal rights. However, the Court emphasised that the discretion to order such testing had to be exercised cautiously.


It was noted that an application for DNA testing ought to be made in good faith, founded on reasonable grounds, and should not be intended to embarrass or economically exploit the person to be tested or amount to an abuse of court process.


Secondly, the Court considered Annette C.N.L. Ntulume v Ssekisaka Aron & Others, Miscellaneous Application No. 2597 of 2024, [2025] UGHCFD 79.

In that matter, the High Court declined to order DNA testing because the application was premature, insufficiently supported and scientifically impractical in the circumstances presented.


The Court observed that this decision demonstrated the importance of establishing whether the proposed participants and available reference samples could scientifically answer the particular question in dispute.

The Court emphasised that;

"A DNA test is not useful merely because it can be performed; it must be capable of producing evidence relevant to the issue the Court is required to determine."

Thirdly, the Court considered Musinguzi Henry Bitature & Another v Joyce Loumo Choudry & Others, Miscellaneous Application No. 385 of 2025, [2025] UGHCFD 42.


The Court noted that the decision addressed an application for kinship DNA testing and the alternative of exhuming the remains of a deceased person. It considered the absence of an express statutory provision regulating compulsory DNA sampling, the rights of the persons concerned and the need to consider less intrusive methods of establishing biological relationships.


The Court further referred to the Court of Appeal's decision in Joyce Loumo Choudry v Musinguzi Henry Bitature & Another, Civil Application No. 406 of 2025, [2025] UGCA 295.


It was observed that the Court of Appeal had considered the right to ascertain biological parentage and the interests of persons claiming a relationship with a deceased person. The decision supported the proposition that the interest in establishing biological parentage was not necessarily extinguished merely because the person seeking to establish that relationship had attained adulthood.


Nevertheless, the High Court cautioned that the Court of Appeal had been determining an application for stay of execution and had not finally determined the legal limits governing every order for compulsory DNA testing.


Having considered the foregoing authorities, the Court clarified that neither the existence nor the denial of a biological relationship automatically entitled a party to DNA testing.


The Court formulated the relevant considerations as follows:

  1. Whether there was a genuine dispute concerning the biological relationship.

  2. Whether the alleged relationship was material to the proceedings.

  3. Whether there were reasonable grounds supporting the assertion of the relationship.

  4. Whether the proposed DNA examination was a suitable and proportionate means of resolving the dispute.


The Court therefore rejected the proposition that an applicant must first prove the very biological relationship that the proposed DNA examination is intended to establish before an order for testing can be considered.


Whether the alleged biological relationship was material to the substantive land dispute

Applying the above principles to the facts before it, the Court found that the alleged biological relationship was directly relevant to the determination of the substantive civil suit.


It was noted that the Applicant's claim to an interest in the disputed land was founded, at least in part, on her alleged status as a descendant of the late Veria Nakanyike.


The Respondent, on the other hand, disputed that relationship and challenged the Applicant's asserted basis for claiming an interest in the property.


The Court therefore found that determining whether the parties were biologically related in the manner alleged was capable of affecting the determination of their respective claims in the main suit.


In this regard, the Court observed:

"The dispute is not peripheral to the main suit."

It further held that:

"Whether the Applicant is biologically related to the Respondent in the manner alleged is therefore a matter capable of affecting the determination of the parties' respective claims in the main suit."

The Court accordingly considered the proposed DNA examination relevant to the determination of the substantive dispute.


Whether the Applicant had provided sufficient evidence to support the application

The Respondent had argued that the Applicant failed to produce birth certificates, family records or affidavits from other relatives to corroborate the alleged biological relationship.


The Court acknowledged that such evidence would undoubtedly have strengthened the Applicant's case. However, it rejected the argument that the absence of such documents automatically barred the application.


The Court held that the absence of a birth certificate or supporting affidavit from another relative was not, by itself, a statutory bar to an application for DNA testing.

It stated:

"The absence of a birth certificate or a supporting affidavit from another relative is not, without more, a statutory bar to an application for DNA testing."

The Court nevertheless disagreed with the Applicant's submission that the Respondent's affidavit in reply amounted to a general denial.


It found that the Respondent's denial was specific because she had disputed the identity of the alleged common mother, denied knowing the Applicant and challenged the Applicant's assertion concerning the alleged custody of her children.


The Court further noted that the Applicant had not filed an affidavit in rejoinder to respond to those specific allegations, despite having been afforded an opportunity to do so.


However, the Court clarified that the failure to file an affidavit in rejoinder did not automatically mean that every averment in the affidavit in reply had been admitted.

In the Court's words:

"The absence of a rejoinder does not automatically convert every averment in the affidavit in reply into an admitted fact."

The Court reasoned that the Respondent's denial of the alleged biological relationship was itself the very issue that the proposed scientific examination was intended to investigate. Accordingly, such denial could not, standing alone, resolve the biological question in the Respondent's favour.


The effect of the Respondent's land title and previous judgment

The Court also considered the Respondent's reliance on the title to the disputed land, which she alleged had been transferred to her in 2005 during the lifetime of her grandmother.


It further considered the Respondent's reliance on the judgment in Kalisa Angelo & Another v Nandutu Harriet, Civil Suit No. 004 of 2024, in which the Applicant was allegedly declared a trespasser.


The Court found that those matters could be relevant to the parties' competing claims over the property and to the question of the Applicant's alleged motive for seeking DNA testing.


However, the Court held that they did not conclusively determine whether the parties shared a biological mother.


It was emphasised that the questions concerning ownership of the land, the validity of any transfer, the rights of third-party purchasers and the effect of the earlier judgment were matters to be determined in the appropriate proceedings.


The Court therefore declined to finally determine those questions in the interlocutory application.


The scientific limitations of sibling kinship testing

An important aspect of the ruling was the Court's recognition that sibling kinship testing does not necessarily produce an absolute or conclusive answer in every case.

The Court noted that both the Applicant and Respondent were female and that the Applicant alleged that they shared a common biological mother.


It observed that the precise scientific method required to establish that relationship, the degree of probability that could be established and whether additional reference samples would be necessary were matters falling within the expertise of qualified forensic scientists.


The Court therefore cautioned against making assumptions about the scientific conclusions that would emerge from the proposed examination.

It held that:

"The Court should not assume, without expert guidance, that the Applicant and Respondent are uterine siblings."

Having considered the evidence, the Court concluded that the dispute was genuine and that the alleged biological relationship was material to the main suit.


The Court further found that although the absence of documentary corroboration weakened the Applicant's case, the proposed scientific inquiry was relevant and capable of providing useful evidence for determining the substantive civil suit.


Importantly, the Court was satisfied that the application had not been shown to have been brought solely to embarrass or economically exploit the Respondent.

It therefore considered it appropriate to facilitate a properly controlled scientific examination, subject to confirmation by the laboratory that the proposed test was scientifically capable of addressing the question and that the procedure would respect the dignity and privacy of the parties.


The Court finally held:

"Accordingly, I find that the Applicant has established sufficient grounds for the Court to facilitate DNA kinship testing for the limited purpose of investigating whether she and the Respondent share the same biological mother or are siblings and this finding shall determine the substantive issues of the main suit."

Whether the Respondent's request for exhumation of her late mother's remains could be granted

Having found that DNA testing was justified in principle, the Court proceeded to consider the appropriate orders and remedies available to the parties.

The Respondent had proposed that the remains of her late mother be exhumed to establish whether the Applicant was her biological child.

However, the Court declined this alternative request on both procedural and substantive grounds.

On the procedural aspect, the Court observed that the substantive application before it had been instituted by the Applicant for an order facilitating DNA testing between herself and the Respondent.

The Respondent's request for exhumation had only been raised in her affidavit in reply and submissions. It was therefore not a substantive prayer in a properly constituted application for exhumation.


The Court further noted that the persons who might be affected by an exhumation order had not been brought before Court for that purpose.

On the substantive aspect, the Court considered exhumation to be a substantially more intrusive measure and held that it should not be considered before establishing whether a less intrusive method involving living relatives was unavailable or incapable of resolving the question.


In this regard, the Court relied on Mukwaya Badru v Ssentamu Moses & 7 Others, Civil Appeal No. 19 of 2021, [2022] UGHCCD 5, and reiterated the importance of considering the least intrusive scientifically suitable method of establishing biological relationships.


The Court accordingly declined the Respondent's request for exhumation, without prejudice to any properly constituted application that might become necessary upon appropriate evidence.


Protection of the Respondent's privacy, dignity and bodily integrity

The Court was particularly mindful that the Respondent was an adult who had expressly opposed the proposed DNA examination.


It therefore considered it necessary to frame the order in a manner that protected her constitutional rights, particularly her right to privacy and bodily integrity.


The Court made it clear that although it had jurisdiction to facilitate DNA testing, that jurisdiction did not authorise the use of physical force to obtain biological samples from an adult.


It consequently directed that the examination be conducted in a manner that respected the dignity, privacy and bodily integrity of both parties.


The Court further directed that the Government Analytical Laboratory at Wandegeya determine the appropriate scientific method and samples required to establish whether the parties shared the same biological mother.


This ensured that the order was not an unrestricted authorisation to collect or analyse the parties' genetic material for purposes unrelated to the dispute.


Costs of the application

On the question of costs, the Court considered section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap. 282, which gives Court discretion to determine by whom and out of what property costs should be paid.

The Court observed that the application concerned a disputed family relationship that was also relevant to the determination of the substantive land dispute.

In the circumstances, it considered it appropriate that the costs of the application abide the outcome of the main suit.

It separately directed that any costs arising from conducting the DNA sibling kinship test be met by the Applicant, since she was the party who had sought the examination.


HOLDING AND ORDERS OF COURT

The High Court allowed the application and made the following orders:

  1. A DNA sibling kinship test was ordered to establish whether the Applicant, Nandutu Harriet, and the Respondent, Adeke Sarah, were uterine sisters or shared the same biological mother.

  2. The examination was directed to be conducted by the Government Analytical Laboratory at Wandegeya, Kampala.

  3. The Laboratory was directed to determine and employ the appropriate scientific method, including the samples required to establish the question of biological maternity.

  4. Both parties were directed to attend the Government Analytical Laboratory on a date to be communicated to them by the Laboratory.

  5. The Laboratory was directed to conduct the examination in a manner that respected the dignity, privacy and bodily integrity of the parties.

  6. Any costs arising from the DNA sibling kinship examination were to be borne by the Applicant.

  7. The Laboratory was directed to prepare and transmit its report to Court, indicating the findings of the examination and any relevant scientific limitations, for purposes of determining Civil Suit No. 779 of 2025.

  8. The Respondent's alternative request for the exhumation of the remains of her late mother, Namiyingo Hellen, was declined because there was no substantive application before Court seeking such an order.

  9. The costs of the application were ordered to abide the outcome of the substantive civil suit.


Read the full case


KEY TAKEAWAYS

  1. The decision reaffirms that section 98 of the Civil Procedure Act preserves the inherent jurisdiction of Court to make orders necessary for the ends of justice. This jurisdiction may extend to facilitating DNA testing where establishing a biological relationship is material to the determination of a civil dispute.

  2. The Court clarified that requiring an applicant to establish the very biological relationship that the proposed examination is intended to investigate would defeat the purpose of the scientific inquiry. What is required is sufficient evidence establishing a genuine dispute, the materiality of the relationship and reasonable grounds for the proposed examination.

  3. The Court emphasised that the power to facilitate DNA testing must be exercised judiciously. Courts must consider whether the dispute is genuine, whether the relationship is material to the proceedings, whether there are reasonable grounds supporting the application and whether the proposed examination is suitable and proportionate.

  4. The absence of birth certificates or family records does not automatically defeat an application for DNA testing.

  5. The Court reaffirmed that the absence of a rejoinder does not automatically convert every averment in an affidavit in reply into an admitted fact. Nevertheless, an applicant who fails to respond to specific factual allegations risks leaving material aspects of their case unanswered, which may weaken the application.

  6. The collection and analysis of genetic material implicates an individual's bodily and information privacy. Consequently, orders facilitating DNA testing must be carefully framed to protect the dignity, privacy and bodily integrity of the persons involved.

  7. The Court emphasised that a DNA test must be capable of producing evidence relevant to the question before Court. The appropriate methodology, the reliability of the proposed test, the probability of establishing the relationship and the need for additional reference samples are matters that should be determined by qualified forensic experts.

  8. The Court recognised that the denial of kinship is precisely what may necessitate scientific investigation. A party cannot rely solely on denying the alleged relationship to defeat an otherwise properly founded application for DNA testing.

  9. The decision demonstrates that questions of biological parentage and sibling relationships may be material to determining entitlement to property, particularly where a party claims an interest in land through inheritance or descent. Courts may therefore facilitate scientific investigations where the outcome could assist in resolving competing claims to property.


Comments


LEAVE A REPLY

Thanks for submitting!

Writing in Notepad

Write for Us

Appointing New Writers

We're actively seeking passionate researchers and writers to join our team. If you're enthusiastic about sharing knowledge and contributing to our platform, we'd love to hear from you. Don't hesitate to apply – your expertise could make a significant impact on our community's learning experience.

Green Modern Real Estate Agent Linkedin Banner (1).jpg

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Be the first to know about our events, conferences, workshops, live training and consultations.

SUCCESSFULLY SUBSCRIBED!

Green Modern Real Estate Agent Linkedin Banner.jpg
bottom of page